Back to index

Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency: Commencing a Comprehensive Strategy

RECOMMENDATION SUMMARY:

Accelerate growth in the renewable energy and energy efficiency sectors by implementing the following four fiscal strategies, as part of a comprehensive national strategy:

  1. Increased renewable energy production incentives,
  2. Additional transfers to provinces and municipalities for investments in energy efficiency and renewable energy,
  3. Continued support for buildings retrofit programs, and
  4. Tax measures to support phasing out inefficient lighting by 2015.

The GBC stresses that these recommendations are part of a recommended national strategy for renewable energy and energy efficiency. To understand more about how these measures contribute to an overall plan, please see National Strategy (below).

Investment Required
$5 billion over 8 years (2007-2014)

Benefits for Canadians

  • Provide a secure, reliable energy supply,
  • Reduce vulnerability to conventional energy price volatility,
  • Limit the additional cost to the economy posed by higher fossil fuel prices,
  • Develop a competitive renewable energy and energy effi ciency sector capable of capitalizing on the fastest growing energy sectors worldwide,
  • Increase access to new export markets for Canadian enterprises,
  • Create meaningful, geographically dispersed employment in the renewable energy and energy efficiency sectors,
  • Reduce harmful air and water pollution caused by combustion of fossil fuels, and
  • Protect the climate by reducing greenhouse gas pollution from fossil fuels.

TOP

Background and Rationale

Maximizing energy efficiency and supporting a transition to renewable energy is the most effective way of cleaning Canada’s air, protecting the health of Canadians, and meeting our climate change responsibilities. Energy efficiency measures and renewable sources of energy reduce air emissions, have water and land use benefits, improve energy security and local control, provide employment and economic opportunities in all parts of the country, and prepare business and consumers for the inevitable transition away from fossil fuels.

Canada must therefore make energy effi ciency the cornerstone of energy policy, and renewable energy its primary focus. By working collaboratively with provinces and stakeholders to pursue a comprehensive renewable energy and energy effi ciency strategy, Canada can accelerate growth in these important sectors. These industries will contribute to increased energy security and protection of our climate, air and water.

The Coalition’s vision of a national renewable energy and energy efficiency strategy is outlined at the end of this recommendation. The Coalition has identified four strategic fiscal measures that deserve primary consideration for the 2007 federal budget.

TOP

Detailed Recommendations for 2007 Budget

Take strategic actions to accelerate growth in the renewable energy and energy efficiency sectors, by:

1. Increasing and broadening support for Renewable Energy through Production Incentives.

The Green Budget Coalition recommends that a new comprehensive production incentive program for low-impact renewable electricity and heat technologies be implemented by expanding support for low impact renewable electricity generation in Canada to a total of 12,000 MW by 2013. This would build on and replace the current 4,000 MW Wind Power Production Incentive and proposed 1,500 MW Renewable Power Production Incentive.

This program would:
1) Apply to all low-impact renewable energy technologies producing power and heat,
2) Set aside specific funds for each technology, and
3) Vary the support rate by technology, and be based on the market needs of each technology.

For large projects the support should be in the form of a production incentive paid on the basis of measured production of renewable power or heat. For smaller projects a single capital manufacturers or distributors incentive should be paid based on the standard performance of the equipment.

Budget: $2.5 billion over 8 years (2007-2014)

TOP

2. Increasing transfers to provinces and municipalities for investments in Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

The Green Budget Coalition recommends that there be dedicated increases in federal transfers to provinces and municipalities, for investment in:

  • Efficient low-income housing ($500 million),
  • Community energy plans and innovative financing,
  • Public transit and intercity passenger transport,
  • Energy conservation for personal vehicle and freight,
  • Minimizing freight movement and shifting freight and personal modes of transportation to improve efficiency,
  • Urban design to reduce demand for transportation, and
  • Municipal community energy planning and innovative financing through expansion of the Green Funds program.

Budget: $2 billion over 3 years

TOP

3. Continuing support for Energy Efficient Buildings Programs.

The Green Budget Coalition recommends continued support by the federal government for successful core buildings retrofit programs such as the EnerGuide for Houses and EnerGuide for Existing Buildings (for commercial, institutional and industrial buildings). The role of the federal government should include maintenance of national labeling and quality assurance, together with financial incentives for home and building owners. The objective would be to make buildings retrofit a national priority, with most buildings upgraded in 10 years. Special attention should be given to support for energy efficiency retrofits for low-income housing and small-medium enterprises (see provincial and municipal transfers above for recommendation on low-income housing).

Budget:
EnerGuide for (Existing) Houses:
$500 million over five years
EnerGuide for (Existing) Buildings:
$300 million over five years.

TOP

4. Tax measures to support phasing out inefficient lighting by 2015.

A collaborative national “Strategic Lighting Initiative” to phase out inefficient lighting by 2015 has been established by federal and provincial governments, the lighting industry, and electrical utilities. The Green Budget Coalition recommends that the federal government move quickly to support this initiative with tax and other fiscal measures, including providing a long-term program of tax-credits for high efficiency lighting equipment.

Budget: A five-year budget should be developed in collaboration with other partners in the Strategic Lighting Initiative

Alternative and Complementary Polices
The Green Budget Coalition further recommends the following measures be considered for the 2007 budget, for their potential to support the above strategies in accelerating growth in renewable energy and energy efficiency.

The Drive Green: Company Car Tax Shift. This proposal, modeled on a successful measure introduced in the United Kingdom, would encourage employees to drive more fuel-efficient company vehicles by shifting some of the tax burden from green cars to gas guzzlers. (See Ongoing Recommendations, later in document, for more details.)

Switch Green: Energy Star Appliance Feebate. This initiative would reduce the energy consumption of appliances in Canada. By offering a 6% rebate on appliances that meet the Energy Star criteria, and levying a 6% fee on those that do not, this proposal utilizes a revenue-neutral policy instrument to eliminate the price gap between efficient and inefficient appliances. (See Ongoing Recommendations, later in document, for more details.)

Removing Class 43.1 restrictions on solar technologies. Class 43.1 provides an accelerated write off for many renewable energy technologies. However the qualifying restrictions placed on solar energy in Class 43.1 eliminates approximately 90% of the applications for solar energy. The Green Budget Coalition recommends that the size restrictions for solar PV systems in Class 43.1, and the restrictions on applications for solar hot water systems and solar air heating systems, be removed.

Establishing a 100,000 Solar Roofs Program (Solar PV). Under this initiative 200 MW of PV systems could be installed across Canada over a 10-year period, thus encouraging direct engagement by residential owners in managing their own electricity costs. The cost of this program is estimated at $416-460 million over a period of ten years or more.

Federal procurement: Make commitments to purchase 20% of all the federal government’s heating needs from “green heat” renewable sources of energy (solar water heaters, solar walls, biomass, and earth energy). Make commitments to set aside at least 10% of the government’s purchase of green power from solar PV sources.

Substantial funds could be generated to offset the cost of implementing these renewable energy and energy efficiency strategies by reducing the high Accelerated Capital Cost Allowance for oil sands development to a level similar to that of conventional oil and natural gas. (See Oil Sands: Leveling the Playing Field with Other Energy Sources, later in document, for more details.)

The implementation of a Regulated greenhouse gas (GHG) Emissions Targets-and-Trading System for heavy industry, domestic aviation and other large emitters is another key opportunity to reduce GHGs while stimulating integrated economic and environmental benefits. (See Ongoing Recommendations, later in document, for more details.)

National Strategy
In order for the above recommendations to provide their maximum benefits, Canada must simultaneously develop an overall national strategy to support renewable energy and energy efficiency. The Green Budget Coalition recommends that the federal government establish energy efficiency and renewable energy as priorities in Canada by providing strategic funding or incentives and/or by removing barriers, in order that the full benefits of increased penetration of renewable energy and energy efficiency in Canadian economies be realized, including provision of clean air and energy security, and mitigation of dangerous levels of climate change.

In addition to the above fiscal recommendations, a national strategy should contain the following regulatory, policy and core program elements. The Green Budget Coalition believes the federal government must move quickly to:

  1. Set ambitious short and long range targets for energy efficiency and renewable energy. The federal government, working with multi-stakeholder forums should establish these targets in 2007.
  2. Develop and implement a national sustainable transport action plan in collaboration with provinces and territories, and set up appropriate collaborative coordinating bodies.
  3. Use the Energy Efficiency Act to raise existing minimum performance standards for equipment to the best levels found in North America, and extend legal standards to all other energy using equipment, including cars and light trucks. Performance standards should be reviewed and updated on a three-year cycle. The International Energy Agency “1 Watt” initiative should also be adopted by the federal government under the Energy Efficiency Act.
  4. Support provincial energy code regulations by regularly updating the National Model Codes for Houses and Buildings, and incorporating these requirements into the National Building Code by 2008. The federal government should also continue to expand best in class (e.g. Energy Star) labeling protocols for equipment, buildings, and vehicles.
  5. Expand the budget and scope of the core capacity building and quality assurance programs such as EnerGuide for Houses, EnerGuide for Existing Buildings, Energy Star, CIPEC, Industrial Energy Innovators, in order to capitalize on the important knowledge, experience and brand recognition they have developed over more than a decade. These cost effective programs require expanded, stable funding to increase penetration of energy efficient practices and technologies in their respective market sectors.
  6. Honour commitments made by Canada at the 2006 G8 summit in Russia by providing adequate resources for full participation by Canadian governments, businesses and non-governmental organizations in this global initiative.
  7. Immediately implement an efficient technology procurement strategy for all owned and leased buildings, focusing in year 1 on the purchase of best-in-class high efficiency lighting, air conditioning, and vehicles.

See a more detailed description of a national strategy.

Contacts:

Roger Peters
The Pembina Institute
819-483-6288 ext 22
rogerp@pembina.org

Marlo Raynolds
The Pembina Institute
403-269-3344 ext 113
marlor@pembina.org

Stephen Hazell
Sierra Club of Canada
613-241-4611
shazell@sierraclub.ca

Pierre Sadik
David Suzuki Foundation
613-594-5845
psadik@davidsuzuki.org

TOP